17 April, 2013 14:00 ▪
Olga Shumylo-Tapiola: enlargement carrot will not work in Ukraine as it did in Poland
“Growing disappointment with Yanukovych after endless failed attempts to reach out to him turned even the last do-gooders away from idealism. Talking about Ukraine became emotionally difficult, and these states did not see much sense in pushing the rest of the EU toward signing the agreement at any cost. They had other, more important issues to talk about with the heavyweights like Germany and France. Wasting political capital on Ukraine, even given the Russia factor, no longer seemed worth it,” expert claims.
“The positions of all member states are now coalescing around the vision of waiting for the situation on the ground to improve while keeping the option of signing the agreement open. They primarily seek not to promote European values in Ukraine but to ensure that the EU does not compromise its own values because of the geopolitical fears of certain EU member states. Some idealists are still trying to influence the situation on the ground, but even their hopes are bound to eventually fade,” she notes.
“EU member states should agree to pause the EU enlargement debate and deliver a clear message to Ukraine. The sad truth is that the EU does not have the institutional capacity or will to enlarge beyond a few Balkan countries. It is also clear that the enlargement carrot will not work in Ukraine as it did in Poland. Erasing the issue of enlargement from the Ukraine debate will help the EU be more pragmatic and less emotional about Ukraine. It will tame Kyiv’s bloated sense of self-importance and help it understand Ukraine’s interest-based relevance for the EU27.
The EU should end its unnecessary rhetoric about competition over Ukraine with Russia. Toning down the rhetoric does not mean that the EU is giving Ukraine away to the Eurasian Customs Union. Rather, it means stopping Kyiv from playing Brussels against Moscow and letting Ukraine decide its direction independently,” believes Shumylo-Tapiola.
- Ukraine disappointed with EU sanctions against Russia
- European Commission says Gazprom’s threats against reverse supplies of gas to Ukraine are unacceptable
- EU delays sanctions against Russia until June 30
- Ukraine signs Association Agreement with EU
- Premier Yatseniuk links disruption of gas talks to the signing of the Association Agreement
- Matthew Rojansky: scrutiny and criticism of Ukraine’s record on human rights and democracy issues will surely continue after the Association Agreement is signed
- Tadeusz Olszański: Lutsenko’s release is the only concession which President Yanukovych and his entourage are willing to make
- European Court on Human Rights urges Ukraine to update Soviet-era laws on peaceful assembly
- Pawel Kowal: Lutsenko`s pardon was the success of Ukrainian government, opposition, European diplomats and politicians but not that of Ukraine
- Business New Europe: nothing will happen in the talks with EU until Tymoshenko is released – and that is very unlikely to happen